I am not sure that what the poster claims is accurate. Numbers like these alone do not a successful presidency make.
A successful presidency would not have lost control of the House in 2012 and both houses of Congress in 2014. A successful presidency would have chewed up the Republican base by now. But the opposite happened. The Republicans chewed up the Democrat base. Some of the numbers look good because at the end of Bush, the country was in an economic free fall.
Obama could have been much more successful. A number of things went wrong, and the Democrats and Obama better figure it out in the next couple of years – or else.